Introduction
The Human Rights First Ethiopia report details how Tigray natives are subjected to biased treatment when applying for passports. The organization, operating under Civil Society Organizations Proclamation No. 1113/2011, conducted its investigation by speaking directly with affected individuals and observing physically the processing procedures at the Immigration and Citizenship Service.
Key Issues Identified:
- Discriminatory Office Practices:
Applicants with names that appear Tigrayan background are consistently directed to a specific office (No. 07), where they face heightened scrutiny and harsh treatment. Reports from these applicants describe a hostile environment, with staff exhibiting discriminatory behavior and a lack of respect for individuals of Tigrayan descent.
- Case Studies Highlighting Injustices:
- Mr. Gebre Christos (Pseudonym): A prosecutor with the Ministry of Justice was mistakenly labeled as Eritrean and denied a passport despite his clear Ethiopian citizenship and a position that requires such citizenship. His experience underscores the broader implications of these discriminatory practices.
- Mr. Atsbeha Gebre (Pseudonym): A long-time resident of Addis Ababa was required to provide documentation from deceased relatives, illustrating the arbitrary and unreasonable demands placed on Tigrayan individuals.
- Adey Letheran (Pseudonym): A 70-year-old woman, also a long-time resident of Addis Ababa, sought a passport to visit her daughter in the UK but faced repeated refusals unless she provided identification from deceased parents. This situation highlights the bureaucratic obstacles that hinder passport issuance, ultimately preventing her from seeing her daughter.
- Berhan (Pseudonym): A 19-year-old student from Tigray was found crying in the compound of the Authority. When asked about her distress, she explained that she was denied a passport despite submitting all required documents, as additional demands were imposed on her, including proof from a school in Tigray that had been destroyed.
Legal Violations
The report identifies several constitutional violations, including:
- Article 33: The right to Ethiopian citizenship cannot be arbitrarily stripped. Denying Tigray natives their citizenship rights contravene this principle.
- Article 25: All individuals are entitled to equal protection under the law. The discriminatory practices against Tigray applicants violate this constitutional guarantee.
- Article 32: The right to freedom of movement, including obtaining a passport, is being restricted through arbitrary and discriminatory practices.
Recommendations for Reform
Human Rights First Ethiopia calls for urgent reforms to address these issues:
- Ensure Constitutional Compliance: Immediate action is needed to uphold the rights guaranteed by Articles 6, 25, 32, and 33 of the Constitution. The Immigration and Citizenship Service must eliminate discriminatory practices.
- Equal Service Provision: Passport issuance procedures must be standardized to ensure that Tigray natives receive the same level of service as other citizens.
- Streamlined Procedures: Establish a new service branch in the Tigray region and implement uniform procedures to simplify and expedite passport applications.
- Legislative and Institutional Reforms: Introduce clear directives to prevent arbitrary demands and ensure fair treatment for all passport applicants.
Legal Action
If these issues are not addressed, Human Rights First Ethiopia will pursue legal action under Federal Courts Decree No. 1234/2013. The aim is to correct systemic injustices and enforce the constitutional rights of Ethiopian citizens.
The findings of this report cast a spotlight on serious flaws within the Immigration and Citizenship Service and emphasize the need for immediate reform to protect the rights of all Ethiopians.
